top of page

Poughkeepsie's Witch Shop Stands Its Ground Against a Petition

2 days ago
2 min read

Pour yourself some magical herbal tea, because this one feels very familiar. A beloved witch shop in New York's Hudson Valley is facing a petition, and its neighbors are speaking up for it.


Cozy witchy shop window at twilight with candles, crystals, dried herbs, tarot cards and an old spellbook, a misty bridge and crescent moon behind, with a faint map of Poughkeepsie under the headline "The Witch Shop Stands Its Ground."

Mid-Hudson News reports that Aaron Scott, who lives in Poughkeepsie's Mt. Carmel neighborhood (also known as Little Italy, in the shadow of the Walkway Over the Hudson), started an online petition against the Witchcraft District Bazaar. The shop opened on Mt. Carmel Place in 2021.


Scott says his religious beliefs motivated the campaign. His original petition called for relocating what it described as a "witchcraft-satanic store." After a backlash on social media, he revised it. Scott told the outlet that the relocation wording was generated by AI on Change.org and that he removed it a few days later. He now says his goal is only to stop the city from officially naming the area the "Witchcraft District," after he saw placards with that name around the neighborhood.


City officials say no such designation is being considered. Mayor Yvonne Flowers said the city has not approved the designation or the signage.


The Witchcraft District Bazaar is owned by Priestess Renee Anderson and Reverend Storm Anderson. According to its website, it sells witchy creations, witchcraft supplies, healing crystals, occult items, books, jewelry, and magically charged artwork. It has become a popular destination since it opened. Former First Ward Councilman Chris Petsas, a lifelong resident, wrote on the petition that the effort could "legitimately harm the business community" and that the shop's owners have helped revive the neighborhood.


The owners have no plans to move. Five years in, it sounds like this little corner of magic is staying exactly where it is.


🔮 Do you have a favorite local witch shop? Tell us about it, and what it means to your community, in the comments.



Source: Mid-Hudson News, "Neighborhood witches become a cause for concern (VIDEO)" by Todd Bender, Nov. 18, 2026.

Comments


ParaHouse Good Witch Study spells magic shop
ParaHouse Magazine annual subscription 2026.PNG
bottom of page